Skip to main content

Table 7 List of factors and their references

From: Assessing the performance of urban heritage conservation projects – influencing factors, aspects and priority weights

Papers

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

Physical Aspect

 1

Preservation of the historic built environment

        

*

     

*

 2

Preservation of the urban pattern and issues of the historic city

              

*

 3

Preservation of the overall style and features of the conservation area

        

*

     

*

 4

Heritage authenticity and interpretation

              

*

 5

Environmental enhancement

              

*

 6

Spatial transformation of the historic built form

        

*

     

*

 7

The compatibility of older land uses with new land uses

              

*

 8

Adaptation of the historic quality of the mixed-use environment to modern conditions

        

*

     

*

 9

Infrastructure improvement

              

*

 10

Buffer zone treatment

       

*

       

Social Aspect

 1

Residents’ living standards

 

*

           

*

*

 2

The community of low-income residents should be retained

   

*

    

*

   

*

 

*

 3

Supporting strategy for low-income residents when relocation is unavoidable

   

*

    

*

     

*

 4

Low-income residents are protected from the impact of gentrification

   

*

    

*

   

*

 

*

 5

Public participation

 

*

  

*

*

*

 

*

*

   

*

*

 6

Public and private initiatives

        

*

     

*

 7

The maintenance of public openness during the decision-making process

      

*

      

*

*

 8

Social cohesion

               

 9

Tourism and the host community

*

            

*

 

Economic Aspect

 

 1

Economic needs

 

*

           

*

*

 2

The economic viability of conservation

           

*

 

*

*

 3

The funding system

              

*

 4

Financial support

  

*

          

*

*

 5

Taking advantage of private and public resources

              

*

 6

Land value and taxes

           

*

 

*

*

 7

Special tourist interest

              

*

 8

Consolidation of the urban economy

  

*

          

*

*

Cultural Aspect

 1

Enhance the sense of place and local culture

 

*

*

           

*

 2

Retain significant meaning and associations with the community

 

*

            

*

 3

Cultural needs

              

*

 4

Conserving culture

 

*

        

*

  

*

*

 5

The strengthening of indigenous cultural traditions and forms

 

*

*

       

*

  

*

*

 6

Enhance identity and collective memory

 

*

      

*

 

*

  

*

*

Political Aspect

 1

The power structure

           

*

  

*

 2

Developing a community and culture-led agenda

          

*

   

*

 3

The planning process

 

*

     

*

  

*

   

*

 4

Relocation of residents

              

*

 5

Incremental renovation

              

*

 6

Policy agendas

       

*

  

*

*

  

*

 7

Management of the heritage site

       

*

      

*

 8

The generation and maintenance of political support

    

*

         

*

 9

The orientation of development

    

*

     

*

    

 10

Cooperation among the central government, the local government, NGOs, and inhabitants

    

*

*

 

*

      

*

Continuity Aspect

 1

Environmental continuity

  

*

          

*

*

 2

Ecological sustainability

             

*

*

 3

Economic sustainability

  

*

       

*

   

*

 4

Socio-cultural sustainability

  

*

       

*

   

*

 5

Political Sustainability

              

*

  1. 1: Byrd (2007); 2. Easterling (2004); 3: Stubbs (2004); 4: Shin (2010); 5: Kwan (2010); 6: Ota (2010); 7: Techera (2011); 8: UNESCO et al. (2013); 9: Boussaa (2014); 10: Endere (2014); 11: Guzman et al. (2018); 12: Amin and Adu-Ampong (2016); 13: Seifolddini and Harris (2017); 14: Rasoolimanesh and Jaafar (2016); 15: Chen, Yoo, and Hwang (2017)